寒松赋：英文投稿过程中的十种状态

2020年11月29日发(作者：成无己)
-------------精选文档-----------------
英文投稿过程中的十种状态
1. Submitted to Journal
当上传结束后，显示的状态是Submitted to Journal，这个状态是自然形成的
无需处理。
2. With editor
如果在投稿的时候没有要求选择编辑，就先到主编那里，主编会分派给别的编辑。
这当中就会有另两个 状态：
① Editor assigned 编辑分派
② Editor Declined Invitation 编辑拒绝邀请，这时主编不得不将投稿文章重
新分派给其它编辑。
3. Reviewer(s) invited
说明编辑已接手处理，正在邀请审稿人中。有时该过程会持 续很长时间，如果其
中原因是编辑一直没有找到合适的审稿人，这时投稿者可以向编辑推荐审稿人。
4. Under review
审稿人的意见已上传，说明审稿人已接受审稿，正在审稿中 ，这应该是一个漫长
的等待（期刊通常会限定审稿人审稿时间，一般为一个月左右）。当然前面各步骤也可能很慢的，要看编辑的处理情况。如果被邀请审稿人不想审，就会decline，
编辑会重 新邀请别的审稿人。
5. required review completed
审稿结束，等编辑处理，该过程短则几天，长则无期，科学堂有一篇文章出现
required review completed状态已近一个月了，还是没有消息。
可编辑
-------------精选文档-----------------
6. Decision in Process
到了这一步就快要有结果了，编辑开始考虑是给修改还是直 接拒，当然也有可能
直接接受的，但可能性很小，呵呵。
7. Minor revisionMajor revision
小修大修，这个时候可以稍微庆祝一下了，因为有修 改就有可能。具体怎么改
就不多说了，谦虚谨慎是不可少的（因为修改后一般会再发给审稿人看，所以一
定要细心的回答每一个审稿人的每一个问题，态度要谦逊，要让审稿人觉得他提
的每个问题都很 有水准的，然后针对他的问题，一个一个的做出答复，能修改的
就修改，不能修改的给出理由，而且都要 列出来，文章的哪一段哪一行修改了最
好都说出来，记住：给审稿人减少麻烦就是给你自己减少麻烦！另 注：有时，审
稿人会在修改意见里隐讳里说出要你仔细阅读某几篇文献，这时可要注意了，其
中 某些文章可能就是评审者自己发表的，这时你最好在你的修改稿中加以引用），
修改后被拒绝的例子也多 不胜数的。
8. Revision Submitted to Journal
修改后重新提交，等待编辑审理。
9. Accepted
如果不要再审，只是小 修改，编辑看后会马上显示这个状态，但如果要再审也会
有上面的部分状态。一步会比较快，但也有慢的 。看杂志的。
可编辑
-------------精选文档-----------------
10. Rejected
相信大家见了Rejected，都会很郁闷。但也不要太灰心，耐心将评审意见看 完，
一般评审者会给出有益的建议，相信看后你会有所收获。
In the Rapid Review? system, your manuscript has a different status assigned to it at various
stages in the process. Below is a list of the status descriptions used with brief explanations.
Incomplete Submission... you have begun the submission process. The submission has been
assigned a temporary (TMP) manuscript number. You must complete the submission process.
Finish My Submission... by viewing and approving the MS PDF. Once this is done, the
submission will be assigned a permanent manuscript number.
MS at Check-In... the manuscript is pending a quality check by the staff or editor. This
involves verifying that the MS PDF contains a complete manuscript (text, tables, figures, etc.) and
is suitable for review purposes.
Conversion to PDF in Process... If the manuscript was submitted digitally, the MS PDF did
not pass the QC process and is not suitable for review purposes. The staff may be in the process
of converting the digital files to a new MS PDF or staff may have requested that the author send
new file(s). The Journal Office is waiting for the file(s) to upload for conversion purposes.
MS Being Pre-screened... if you submitted a manuscript to a journal whose review process
includes pre-screening, this status indicates that the manuscript (or the abstract) is currently
being pre-screened to determine its appropriateness for the journal.
MS In Review... the manuscript has been assigned to an editor and may be awaiting
reviewer selections, or the awaiting reviews.
Decision Pending... the manuscript has been reviewed and the editor is in the process of
making a decision.
MS in Revision (Optional)... a decision to accept the paper with optional revisions (as
suggested in the reviewer or editor comments) has been made by the editor, and a letter
requesting these revisions has been sent to the author. Resubmission is anticipated.
MS in Revision (Minor)... a decision to accept the paper with minor revisions (as suggested
in the reviewer or editor comments) has been made by the editor, and a letter requesting these
revisions has been sent to the author. Resubmission is anticipated.
MS in Revision (Major)... a decision to reconsider the paper after major revisions (as
suggested in the reviewer or editor comments) has been made by the editor, and a letter
requesting these revisions has been sent to the author. Resubmission is permitted.
MS Rejected... a decision to decline publication has been made by the editor, and a
rejection letter has been sent to the author.
可编辑
-------------精选文档-----------------
MS Accepted... a decision to accept the paper has been made by the editor, and an
acceptance letter has been sent to the author.
MS Withdrawn... the manuscript has been withdrawn at the author's request. No
resubmission is permitted. Any further version must be considered as a brand new submission.
MS Deactivated... the manuscript has been deactivated due to the author's non-response in
resubmitting a revised version or, in some instances, to the editor's invitation to submit a
solicited paper.
MS Published... the review process is complete and the manuscript is awaiting publication
or it has already been published.
InvitationSubmit Invited Paper... the editor has extended to you an invitation to submit a
paper on a proposed topic. You are asked to reply by using the
you and the editor are in agreement, you can submit the invited paper by using the
Invited MS
作者: dy_yzh1984 发布日期: 2008-09-08
投稿的时候你会看到很多状态，with review 一般在审稿人那里。有时也会说under reviw 同样的
意思。
1. Submitted to Journal这是投稿时显示的第一个状态，也是系统生成的，说明你的稿件已经上传
到编辑部。
2. With editor这种状态代表编辑已经看到你的投稿件的信息，在此要考虑应该让谁来审理你的稿件。
3. Under review及with editor
这种状态代表稿件在审稿人那里 ，正在审阅。但是如果审稿人对此文章不了解不想审，就会退给编
辑，编辑会重新邀请别的审稿人。
4. required review completed 这种状态代表审稿结束，等编辑处理接受与否。
5. Minor revisionMajor revision 这种状态代表审稿人做出的决定让你小修改或者大修改文章。
6. Revision Submitted to Journal 这是要求修改稿送给编辑，重复以上状态。但 是有可能也不重复，
如果审稿人给你提的问题都是无关紧要的问题，那么编辑回自己做出最后接受的决定 。不会再分配给审稿
人
“Editor invited” 是 邀请安排合适的负责你文章的编辑 的意思
“Editor assigned”是 已经为你的文章确定好了编辑，下一步这个编辑会对你的稿件进行进一步的
处理，
状态是Assessment by Editorial Office ，事件是Manuscript received by Editorial Office ，编
辑评价后送审，目前还没有过编辑评价这一关，如果编辑认为文章的质量基本可以送审了，那么就会under
review了
Technical Check in Progress 编辑在检查你文章中句子及语法有没有问题
可编辑
-------------精选文档-----------------
Needing revise, 必须按照审稿人的要求仔细修改,认真回答问题列表上的所有问题.编辑的信请你仔
细 看看.上面有告诉你的.是否需要重审.一般你按照审稿人的全部要求修改得好的话.不用再审的.比如仅仅是英语句法等小问题.
Decision in Process是编辑做决定的状态，如果是刚 刚投稿，或者会送审，或者直接拒稿；如果是
投稿一段时间了，一般是审稿意见都回来了，这时由编辑更 加审稿人意见决定是否修改还是修改，如果审
稿人意见相左，也有可能需要再次送审。

可编辑